top of page

Can EMDR Create False Memories? What the Research Says

Oct 16
5 min read
Abstract image of the brain and memory for the question can EMDR create false memories
An abstract illustration of the brain and memory.

You're thinking about EMDR.


You've heard it can help.

You've also heard it involves memory.


So a reasonable question comes up:


Can EMDR create false memories?


It's a fair concern.


And the honest answer is more useful than a simple yes or no.


Can EMDR Create False Memories?


The evidence doesn't show that EMDR reliably creates false memories, but no therapy that involves memory is completely immune to suggestion. EMDR isn't designed to uncover or recover memories. When it's practiced as trained, therapists work with what a client already remembers or currently feels, use neutral prompts, and avoid treating new images or details as proof of what happened.


Key Takeaways


  • Memory is reconstructive for everyone, in and out of therapy.

  • EMDR is not a memory-recovery technique.

  • Lab research on eye movements and memory accuracy is mixed.

  • Neutral, non-leading therapy practices reduce the risk of suggestion.


Why People Ask This Question


Memory isn't a recording.


Every time we remember something, we rebuild it.


That's normal.


In the 1990s, there was serious controversy about therapies that tried to "recover" repressed memories, sometimes with harmful results.


EMDR also involves memory and eye movements.


So it's understandable that people want to know whether it can change what they remember.


What the Research Says


Some laboratory studies have explored whether eye movements affect memory accuracy.


For example, a 2018 study by Houben and colleagues suggested lateral eye movements might increase certain false memory errors in healthy volunteers.


A later direct replication by van Schie and Leer did not find that effect.


These studies mostly use word lists or video clips in non-clinical participants, which is quite different from EMDR therapy.


The takeaway isn't "nothing to see here."


It's that the evidence is mixed, and good clinical practice matters.


For more on how EMDR research is debated, read Why Is EMDR So Controversial?


How EMDR Therapists Reduce the Risk of Suggestion


Can EMDR Create False Memories If the Therapist Leads?


Leading questions are a risk in any therapy. That's why EMDR therapists are trained to:


  • Start from what the client already remembers or currently feels

  • Use neutral prompts like "What do you notice?" and "Go with that"

  • Avoid interpreting new images as facts

  • Avoid "memory hunting" or pressuring for earlier memories

  • Discuss memory and suggestibility during informed consent

  • Slow down and consult when legal issues are involved


What If Something New Comes Up?


It happens.


A detail.


An image.


A feeling you hadn't connected before.


That doesn't automatically mean it's a new memory, or a false one.


EMDR focuses on how an experience is stored and how it affects you now, not on proving exactly what happened.


Your therapist won't tell you what it means.


You'll explore it together.


If you want to understand trauma memory more deeply, read What EMDR Therapists Wish Their Clients Knew About Trauma Memory.


The Takeaway


Your question is a good one.


Ask it.


A well-trained EMDR therapist will explain how memory works, how they avoid suggestion, and what to do if something new comes up.


That conversation is part of informed consent, and part of good care.


Meet Dana Carretta-Stein


Dana Carretta-Stein, LMHC
Dana Carretta-Stein, LMHC

Dana Carretta-Stein, M.S., LMHC, EMDRIA Certified Therapist and Approved Consultant, owner of Peaceful Living Mental Health Counseling, has spent years consulting with therapists on complex, high-stakes cases, including developmental trauma, dissociation, and clients who need more stabilization before reprocessing.


Her approach integrates polyvagal theory, IFS, and EMDR's 8-phase framework to help clinicians understand how trauma shapes the nervous system and how that changes the way we prepare, pace, and process.


As The EMDR Coach, Dana teaches therapists to think like neuroscientists, not just diagnosticians.



The EMDR Coach Treatment Planning Workbook


the EMDR Coach Treatment Planning Workbook

Using the EMDR Coach Treatment Planning Workbook, you can map:

  • Client's baseline nervous system state (and how trauma shaped it)

  • Trauma history themes and the negative cognitions that connect them

  • Current triggers and how they shift arousal

  • Resourcing and interweaves that rebuild nervous system capacity


Having a structured, repeatable assessment tool means you're not relying on intuition, you're building a case formulation that accounts for what standard screening misses. → Get the Treatment Planning Workbook


Truth About Healing Podcast


Truth About Healing Podcast Cover

Dana's podcast, Truth About Healing, explores trauma recovery, nervous system healing, burnout, entrepreneurship, EMDR therapy, clinician wellness, and sustainable approaches to mental health and business.


The podcast offers grounded conversations about emotional health, professional growth, perfectionism, nervous system regulation, trauma recovery, and what sustainable healing and leadership actually look like.




EMDR Therapy in Scarsdale and Trauma-Informed Therapy in Westchester


Peaceful Living Waiting Area
Peaceful Living Waiting Area

Many people considering EMDR therapy worry about what might come up and whether it will be accurate. Those are thoughtful questions, and a good therapist will welcome them.


At Peaceful Living Mental Health Counseling, trauma-informed care emphasizes:

  • nervous system regulation

  • collaborative healing

  • individualized pacing

  • emotional safety

  • sustainable therapeutic relationships


Good trauma treatment is not about keeping someone calm all the time.


It's about understanding what their nervous system is communicating, recognizing when they move into fight, flight, freeze, or shutdown, and helping them build the capacity to move through those states without becoming completely overwhelmed or disconnected.



FAQ


Q: Can EMDR create false memories?

A: The evidence doesn't show that EMDR reliably creates false memories, but any therapy involving memory can be influenced by suggestion. EMDR isn't designed to recover memories, and well-trained therapists use neutral, non-leading language to reduce that risk.

A: EMDR isn't a memory-recovery technique. It works with what a person already remembers or currently feels. Sometimes new details or associations come up, but they aren't treated as confirmed facts.

A: Notice it and share it with your therapist. You don't need to decide whether every detail is accurate. The focus is on how the experience is stored and how it affects you now.

A: Talk with your therapist, and possibly your attorney, before processing memories connected to a legal case. Reprocessing can change how vivid or distressing a memory feels, which may matter in legal settings.


If you're an EMDR therapist and want language for discussing memory and suggestibility during informed consent, the Treatment Planning Workbook helps you document history, targets, and what emerges during processing. Get the Workbook →


P.S.

If you're working with a client whose memories may become part of a legal case, consultation before reprocessing is wise. I'm available for EMDR consultation sessions. → Schedule Consultation


CRISIS DISCLAIMER

This blog is educational and is not a substitute for clinical judgment or emergency intervention. If you or someone you're supporting is in immediate danger, call 911, go to your nearest emergency room, or call the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline (call or text 988 in the U.S.).

This content enriches, but does not replace, care from a licensed mental health professional, clinical training, consultation, and professional judgment.

Comments


bottom of page